Wildlines Archives
Volume II, Number 35
September 2, 2003
A publication of the State Environmental Resource Center (SERC) bringing you the most important news on state environmental issues from across the country.
 
 
NEWS FROM THE STATES:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Protecting Isolated Wetlands
States to Fight Relaxation of Power Plant Pollution Standards
Class Action Reform or Class Action Restriction?
 
Maine to Use Alternative Fuel for Heating
Doctors Agree: Sprawl Is Bad for Your Health
Louisiana Creates Aquaculture Advisory Panel
PA Legislator Wants Tougher Energy-Efficiency Standards
MD Governor Supports Renovation Incentives
CA Senate Approves Ban on Coastal Fish Farming
New Jersey Task Force Attacks Billboard Sprawl
Washington to Reconsider 'Green Logging Seal'
NJ Establishes Stricter Waterway Pollution Limits
CA Assembly Forwards Ban on Use of Barges for Offshore Oil
Protecting Isolated Wetlands
In a closely divided 5-4 decision, the US Supreme Court ruled in January 2001 that the federal government no longer had the jurisdiction to protect certain widespread but isolated wetlands. In recent court proceedings the protection afforded to isolated wetlands has been widely interpreted and large amounts of confusion still remain over how isolated wetlands are protected. What is clear are the many important roles wetlands play. Wetlands serve a myriad of functions including improving drinking water quality, regulating water levels, reducing flood and storm damage, providing important habitat to many species, and playing a role in many recreational activities. With large amounts of wetland acreage disappearing each year, it is important to afford protection to wetlands and close the legal loophole eliminating protection for isolated wetlands. It is important for states to step in and fill the void, as Wisconsin did immediately following the Supreme Court's ruling. For more information on how your state can protect isolated wetlands, visit: http://www.serconline.org/wetlands/pkg_frameset.html.
back to top
 
States to Fight Relaxation of Power Plant Pollution Standards (NY Times 8/29)
A day after the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) announced changes to the New Source Review program, states and environmental groups announced their intention to file lawsuits against the rule change. Factories and power plants are no longer required to upgrade their pollution controls if the cost of their expansions or renovations are less than 20 percent of the plant's total cost. The current EPA administrator, Marianne Horinko, along with utility officials argued the old rule was cumbersome and confusing. Many Northeastern states contend most of their air quality problems stem from coal plants in the Midwest and the rule change would only increase that problem. The EPA administrator also commented the new rule may spur new investments in the power grid, even though utility officials were pushing for the regulations long before the blackouts occurred. State officials and environmentalists now fear that hundreds of thousands of tons of additional pollutants may be released by approximately 17,000 factories across the United States. For more information on how your state can protect itself from the four major pollutants emitted from power plants, visit: http://www.serconline.org/clean/index.html.
back to top 
 
Class Action Reform or Class Action Restriction?
The Class Action Fairness Act of 2003 seems to be anything but fair to citizens and other organizations seeking to hold polluting defendants accountable under state laws. According to S 274's language, this act is needed to protect class action participants from potential abuses, to protect interstate commerce, and to prevent class action rulings from becoming the law of the state. That sounds as if it may be an attempt at reform, but rather it is a guise for defendants to potentially move cases from state court to federal court under certain situations. Two conditions that would automatically give a federal district court original jurisdiction would be in cases where "any member of a class of plaintiffs is a citizen of a State different from any defendant," or where the matter of controversy exceeds $5 million. However, the bill does provide instances in which these conditions would not automatically be applicable including cases where "the number of members of all proposed plaintiff classes in the aggregate is less than 100." Even if 100 or more persons did not want to be lumped together in a class action suit they could be. A letter written by the Judicial Conference of the United States to the Senate Judiciary Committee not only opposes this legislation, but said that if it should pass exceptions were needed. One exception would be cases "in which plaintiff class members suffered personal injury or personal property damage within the state, as in the case of serious environmental damage." Recently, in Anniston, Alabama, 3,500 people are recovering damages for PCB contamination that Monsanto and Solutia exposed them to over the years. If S 274 had been in effect, the defendants could have tried to move the case to federal court unnecessarily delaying litigation, denying jurisdiction to the state court, and allowing the defendants to evade state law. The members of the US Senate were not elected to give polluters a chance to escape prosecution in state courts. S 274, if passed, would not only undermine a state's rights and laws, but hurt the citizens it allegedly sets out to protect.
back to top 
 
Maine to Use Alternative Fuel for Heating (Bangor Daily News 8/29)
Maine's Office of Energy Independence and Security will implement a program this winter to use an alternative fuel blend to heat some state buildings. The state wants to take a leadership role in using nontoxic fuels, reducing its reliance on foreign oil, and stimulating the alternative fuel economy. Maine will use a 20/80 blend of biodiesel and standard petroleum diesel to heat a small Augusta office, with the possibility of expanding the program to other buildings in the area. Biodiesel, which is made from animal fat or vegetable oil, burns more cleanly than other fuels and has the added benefit of being generated from what are usually considered waste products. Critics point out that the alternative fuel blend costs 30 cents a gallon more than heating oil and question whether the switch should be made, given Maine's tight budget. But Beth Nagusky, director of the Office of Energy Independence and Security, points out that "through energy conservation and efficiency we should be able to reduce our usage enough to justify paying a premium." Biodiesel can also be used to power vehicles; the Maine Department of Transportation is already using it in some of its fleet.
back to top
 
Doctors Agree: Sprawl Is Bad for Your Health (Smart Growth America and Surface Transportation Policy Project 8/28)
In the first study to link human body weight directly to the built environment, researchers found that sprawl is associated with obesity, hypertension, and lower rates of physical activity. The peer-reviewed study, "Relationship between Urban Sprawl and Physical Activity, Obesity, and Morbidity," was highlighted in special issues of two prestigious medical journals and a companion report by Smart Growth America and the Surface Transportation Policy Project. To make the comparison, Dr. Reid Ewing of the University of Maryland and associates used data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention on the health characteristics of more than 200,000 people in 448 counties in major metropolitan areas across the U.S., along with Census Bureau and other federal statistics to determine the degree of sprawl in each county. People in the most sprawl-heavy counties are an average of six pounds heavier than people in well-planned, compact areas. As sprawl increases, people are more likely to have high blood pressure and be obese, and less likely to walk for exercise or transportation. The study controlled for age, gender, educational level, and smoking. The companion report outlined long- and short-term projects to increase the health of communities, including investing in sidewalks and bike lanes, taking measures to calm traffic, and planning future development near public transportation hubs. For more information on the effects of sprawl, visit: http://www.serconline.org/sprawl/pkg_frameset.html.
back to top
 
Louisiana Creates Aquaculture Advisory Panel (Times-Picayune 8/28)
Gov. Foster signed an Executive Order last week creating the Louisiana Aquaculture Advisory Council. The council will be located within the Governor's office ending a long argument between the Department of Agriculture and the Department of Wildlife and Fisheries over who should have control over fish farming. Originally Gov. Foster vetoed a bill that would have placed aquaculture within the Department of Agriculture because officials had spoken of loosening regulations on cultivating non-native species which may have increased the spread of invasive species. The council will be composed of 22 members including representatives from state government, conservation groups, farm groups, and the aquaculture industry. Recent concerns have grown over invasive species after an angler caught over a dozen Asian carp. For more information on how your state can prevent the spread of invasive species, visit: http://www.serconline.org/invasives/pkg_frameset.html.
back to top
 
PA Legislator Wants Tougher Energy-Efficiency Standards (Post Gazette 8/27)
Rep. Veon announced his intention to introduce legislation next month that would create tougher energy efficiency standards for air conditioners and "smart" electric meters. The legislation is based on a set of recommendations from a former member of the Public Utility Commission (PUC) and current head of Penn Future citizens group, John Hanger. The legislation will call for the PUC to look into making steps toward more efficient air conditioners citing the recent blackout, even though the cost per unit may increase slightly. Summer peaks tend to stress the grid most, he commented, and reducing the amount of power required to run an air conditioner would help during those times. The "smart" meter would allow customers to give back electricity during peak demands by reducing their power intake and receive a payout from the utility company for doing so. For more information on how your state can adopt energy efficiency standards for appliances, visit: http://www.serconline.org/efficiencystandards/index.html.
back to top
 
MD Governor Supports Renovation Incentives (SunSpot.net 8/27)
Maryland Governor Robert Ehrlich, Jr. expressed strong support for a tax incentive program that rewards developers for renovating and reusing older buildings. The state's historic preservation tax credit has been weakened by the General Assembly over the past few years, in an attempt to limit costs. The program is currently scheduled to end in June 2004, but Governor Ehrlich said he would fight to keep it going, calling it "a very important tax incentive, a priority item for our administration." He made the remarks during a ceremony at Centerpoint, a project building more than 200 apartment units and shops in 90 year old buildings on Baltimore's west side. For more information on other ways to stimulate community revitalization, visit: http://www.serconline.org/community/pkg_frameset.html.
back to top
 
CA Senate Approves Ban on Coastal Fish Farming (LA Times 8/28)
If Gov. Gray Davis signs SB 245, farming of salmon, exotic, and genetically modified fish will be banned on California's coast. Ocean farming, or aquaculture, has been criticized by environmental and fishing groups as harmful to wild fish and coastal habitats. Industry experts claim that they will not be affected, however, as California salmon farming is impractical. The bill excludes salmon and steelhead that are being raised to aid recovery efforts in the wild. Oregon has a similar law. For more information on genetically modified fish, see: http://www.serconline.org/transFish/index.html.
back to top
 
New Jersey Task Force Attacks Billboard Sprawl (Star Ledger 8/27)
The Billboard Policy and Procedure Task Review Force issued a report today stating that New Jersey is "oversaturated with billboards" and needs to curtail their development. The task force recommends that billboard development rights be put up for public bid; developers be required to announce their intention to put up a sign to local planning boards even if the billboard is on state land; disclosure rules be tightened over all individuals with at least a 10 percent interest in any billboard; and special waivers now granted by the transportation commissioner alone be reviewed by the Statehouse Commission. The task force believes billboard decisions should also be moved from the Transportation Department to the Department of Environmental Protection. The panel also calls for the one-year 6 percent tax on billboard revenue that was recently approved to be made permanent. The task force did not include a recommendation to ban all billboards from the state.
back to top
 
Washington to Reconsider 'Green Logging Seal' (Seattle Post-Intelligencer 8/27)
The Pinchot Institute for Conservation and the Lanoga Corporation have contributed $25,000 towards the assessment of 1.2 million acres of Western Washington Forests for evaluation for a 'green logging seal.' A review of logging policies is first step in consideration for a seal from one of two organizations -- the Forest Stewardship Council (FSC), which currently certifies public land in 6 states, and the Sustainable Forestry Initiative (SFI). The Department of Natural Resources passed on certification two years ago because the state was developing a 10-year sustainable forestry plan. The earlier assessment by the FSC concluded the forests could receive certification if certain practices were changed including waiting longer before logging an area or leaving more trees behind, permanently preserving some old-growth areas, and hiring more biologists. SFI is currently doing its first assessment. According to the Pinchot Institute this marks the first time a retailer has helped pay for an assessment. The hope of certification supporters is that consumers will increasingly request wood products that come from certified forests where environmentally sensitive logging is followed. For more information on these certifications, visit: http://www.serconline.org/goodwood.html.
back to top
 
NJ Establishes Stricter Waterway Pollution Limits (DEP PR 8/22)
The Department of Environmental Protection Commissioner, Bradley M. Campbell, announced the adoption of new, stricter limits on the amount of fecal coliform going into more than 300 miles of New Jersey waterways. The Environmental Protection Agency has signed off on the standards and is currently reviewing additional limits that would protect the rest of the state. Commissioner Campbell said "Our next step is to track down and identify the sources of fecal coliform contamination in the targeted waterbodies so that we can effectively control, reduce, or eliminate the pollution at its source." Fecal coliform contamination is generally caused by runoff from agriculture, excessive geese or wildlife populations, and poor sanitary and stormsewer practices.
back to top
 
CA Assembly Forwards Ban on Use of Barges for Offshore Oil (LA Times 8/26)
By a party-line vote on Monday, the State Assembly passed AB 16, a bill that bans the use of barges and tankers to deliver offshore oil to refineries. Less spill-prone pipelines would be used instead. The bill has been widely hailed by environmental groups. Gov. Gray Davis has not indicated if he will sign the legislation, which applies only to extractors that were new or expanded as of January 2003. Venoco Inc., the company that would be most affected by the change, has threatened to barge petroleum to Washington State rather than spend the estimated $10-20 million it would take to build a 10-20 mile pipeline.
back to top

For more information about SERC, or to use our services, contact our national headquarters at:
State Environmental Resource Center
106 East Doty Street, Suite 200 § Madison, Wisconsin 53703
Phone: 608-252-9800 § Fax: 608-252-9828
Email: [email protected]