Wildlines Archives
Volume II, Number 26
June 30, 2003
A publication of the State Environmental Resource Center (SERC) bringing you the most important news on state environmental issues from across the country.
 
NEWS FROM THE STATES:
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
 
Antibiotics in Agriculture
Maine Climate Change Law First in the Nation
Pollute First, Get a Permit Later?
 
Midwest Prefers Road Building to Mass Transit
Oregon Moves to Take Back Bush's Big SUV Tax Break
Wisconsin DNR Votes to Require Tougher Mercury Rules
California Classrooms Can Make Students Sick
Groups Decry Alaska's Return to Aerial Wolf Killing
Suburban Sprawl Blamed for Obesity
US, States Look to Eradicate Thirsty Plant in West
Whitewater Sports Gain Recognition in Water Rights Battle
California Taking Aim at Cruise Ships
Antibiotics in Agriculture
The Union of Concerned Scientists (UCS) estimates that 70% of all antibiotics used in the United States -- more that 24 million pounds per year -- are routinely put in the food and water of healthy livestock. More than one half of these drugs are identical to antibiotics doctors rely upon to treat human illness. They are given to animals to make them grow faster on less feed and to compensate for the crowded, unhygienic conditions typically found on today's industrialized livestock "farms." This practice has the unintended impact of increasing the spread of antibiotic resistant bacteria. In a recent move, the McDonald's Corporation announced it will ask its meat suppliers around the world to reduce their dependence on antibiotics; McDonald's expects its suppliers to phase out use of some antibiotics that promote growth in healthy animals, and to significantly reduce use of other antibiotics that typically protect animals against disease. This repositioning is in response to growing pressure worldwide against the practice of using antibiotics in a nontherapeutic manner. Many federal agencies, including the CDC and the FDA, have extensive studies that show that the use of antibiotics in this manner is dangerous and a threat to public health. Yet the federal government has not taken significant action, and instead is taking more time to study the issue. Antibiotics are a critical tool in the fight against disease, but their effectiveness is weakened by current agricultural practices. For more information on how your state can eliminate the practice of using subtherapeutic levels of antibiotics in agriculture visit: http://www.serconline.org/antibiotics/index.html.
back to top
 
Maine Climate Change Law First in the Nation (Portland Press Herald 6/25)
The first law in the nation to set specific goals and a timeline to reduce carbon dioxide pollution was signed by Gov. John Baldacci last week. Elements of the Climate Change Act include the creation of a "climate change action plan" by July 2004 to reduce carbon dioxide levels to 1990 levels by 2010; to 10 percent below 1990 levels by 2020; and, eventually, by as much as 80 percent below 1990 levels. The Department of Environmental Quality will be working with state agencies, businesses, and individuals to facilitate the creation of the action plans. The new law also aims to spur at least 50 partnerships with businesses and nonprofit organizations. According to Rep. Ted Koffman, who sponsored the legislation, "We're not mandating a command-and-control approach as to how we're going to get these emissions down. It could be that, in certain cases, a regulatory approach would be the most effective and appropriate way of achieving some piece of our overall goal. In other cases, it may be education or technical assistance that is needed." Other states, including Rhode Island and Vermont, have begun to tackle the issue by issuing executive orders or forming action plans to address greenhouse gasses.
back to top 
 
Pollute First, Get a Permit Later?
The North Carolina Senate is working on a bill that would allow companies to almost entirely finish construction on a new plant before receiving an air quality permit for any pollution the plant would emit. Senate Bill 945, which was recently approved by the Agriculture, Environment and Natural Resources Committee, is now in the Finance Committee. Proponents argue that the bill is needed to speed up the permitting process and to attract companies to North Carolina. Opponents counter that North Carolina already has more lenient laws on this issue than some of its neighbors. This bill is fundamentally flawed in several ways: To begin with, it completely circumvents public participation and input into the permitting process. If construction is already underway, there's no chance to improve the design of the project or to incorporate new pollution reduction measures as part of the permitting process. This bill makes permitting an "all or nothing" deal, with no opportunity for compromise on projects. Furthermore, it would put an enormous amount of pressure on the regulators issuing permits to approve them, biasing the permitting process and making it more likely that the project would be approved. Similar language passed both the House and Senate last session, but the Legislature couldn't agree on a final version. This bill would put the cart before the horse by putting construction before permitting, and should be opposed.
back to top 
 
Midwest Prefers Road Building to Mass Transit (Indianapolis Star 6/26)
The "Keep it Moving" study released recently by the Joyce Foundation reveals that the Midwest is losing the battle against traffic congestion and air pollution because local governments continue to focus on paving highways -- not building public transit. The study found that, since 1992, Midwestern states spent 83 percent of $42 billion in federal transportation dollars on road and highway projects and, yet, traffic congestion continues to rise. Indiana received poor marks from the study for investing relatively few dollars into public transportation and having high levels of air pollution. Other states in the Midwest faired similarly. In response, Indiana's Department of Transportation reported they had not received enough federal dollars to implement other projects besides building roads. Another report released by The Civil Rights Project at Harvard University said that trends toward more highways hurt minorities in America, who are more likely than whites to rely on public transportation. The American Public Transportation Association on Tuesday released its third in a series of reports on the need for relief from congestion through improved access to public transit. These studies are being released to coincide with the debate US lawmakers are having over how to allocate funds for transportation for several years. For more information on how your state can keep traffic moving, visit: http://www.serconline.org/trafficcongestionrelief/index.html.
back to top
 
Oregon Moves to Take Back Bush's Big SUV Tax Break (ENN 6/26)
Oregon SUV owners who claim their vehicles as a business expense on their federal tax return will end up paying some of what they save to the state if a proposed bill passes. Under President Bush's new tax cut, small business owners can reduce their taxable income by as much as $75,000 by claiming an SUV as a business expense. This is costing Oregon about $750,000 a year at a time when the state faces a $2 billion budget shortfall. The proposed bill disconnects Oregon law from federal law, according to Jackie Dingfelder, one of the bill's sponsors. "It makes good public policy for a number of reasons," Dingfelder said. "It encourages people to buy vehicles that create less pollution, and it puts money back into the state coffers. It's a win-win." The bill, which only applies to larger SUVs and would not affect farmers or construction workers, is currently in the Senate Revenue Committee. For more information on how your state can help the environment and the bottom line at the same time, visit: http://www.serconline.org/fiscal_issues.html.
back to top
 
Wisconsin DNR Votes to Require Tougher Mercury Rules (Milwaukee Journal Sentinel 6/25)
State environmental officials approved new regulations designed to make Wisconsin lakes cleaner and fish safer to eat by forcing major utilities to cut mercury emissions from their power plants. The Natural Resources Board voted unanimously to require four utilities to cut emissions by 40% by 2010 and 80% by 2015 -- making Wisconsin one of the first states to impose such rules. The Department of Natural Resources estimates that cutting mercury emissions by 80% could cost $87 million to $104 million -- or $18 to $21 a year for the average customers. But the utilities say that it could cost more. Despite a 6-0 vote by the board, the rules are likely to run into trouble in the Republican-controlled Legislature, which is expected to echo concerns from business groups that the mercury limits amount to overregulation that harms the business climate. For more information on how your state can reduce mercury poisoning, visit: http://www.serconline.org/mercury/pkg_frameset.html.
back to top
 
California Classrooms Can Make Students Sick (Contra Costa Times 6/27)
California classrooms have poor indoor air quality, according to a recent study by state health officials. The worst offenders are California's 80,000 portable classrooms, which make up almost one-third of its school rooms and are used by 2 million students. Half the portable classrooms failed to meet health guidelines for formaldehyde, which can cause respiratory illness, asthma, and increase the risk of cancer. The formaldehyde comes from construction materials, including wall board and carpet, and continues to contaminate air for years after the rooms are built. Nearly all classrooms have formaldehyde levels that may cause long-term irritation and contribute to cancer risk, according to the report, which may have harmful impacts on children's and teachers' health, reduced learning and reduced educational progress. Read the report at: http://www.arb.ca.gov/research/indoor/pcs/pcs.htm. For more on how your state can protect children's health, visit: http://www.serconline.org/childrenshealth.html.
back to top
 
Groups Decry Alaska's Return to Aerial Wolf Killing (ENS 6/23)
Alaska Governor Frank Murkowski has signed into law a bill that again allows private citizens to shoot wolves from the air over tens of thousands of square miles in areas of Alaska approved for predator control by the Alaska Board of Game. The legislation overturns two statewide ballot measures in 1996 and 2000 that banned public, same-day airborne wolf shooting in any form for any reason, including predator control. Same-day airborne wolf hunting, also known as "land and shoot," is the practice of spotting wolves from a plane and then landing and immediately shooting them from the ground. Environmental groups condemned the legislation. The practice is controversial even among hunters, many who consider the practice unsportsmanlike, unethical and nearly impossible to regulate and can lead to many other violations of hunting regulations such as chasing, herding, and harassing wolves. For more information on how your state can protect wolves, visit: http://www.serconline.org/wolfpreservation/index.html.
back to top
 
Suburban Sprawl Blamed for Obesity (The Boston Globe 6/20)
At the 11th annual Congress for the New Urbanism, an organization that pushes for all new development in the United States to be more compact and walkable, researchers presented more evidence blaming spread-out suburban development for America's obesity epidemic, and for a variety of other public and mental health woes. People who live in the suburbs tend to drive everywhere and do not get exercise by walking, said Lawrence Frank, a professor at the University of British Columbia, who has tracked the weight, height, and home location of 12,000 people in the Atlanta area. Fewer men and women were overweight or obese in dense neighborhoods -- defined as eight dwelling units per acre -- than in places with one home per acre. Suburban culture and monotonous landscapes can also make people depressed, Richard Jackson, Director of Environmental Health at the Centers for Disease Control, told a gathering of planners and architects in Washington. The researchers' assertions drew immediate criticism from home builders and others who decried the studies as scare tactics based on sketchy science. Health is viewed by many planners at the conference as an ideal way to get citizens and politicians thinking about new styles of development. Results of two more studies linking sprawl and health are expected in September. For more on how your state can stop sprawl and revitalize communities, visit: http://www.serconline.org/sprawl/pkg_frameset.html and http://www.serconline.org/community/pkg_frameset.html.
back to top
 
US, States Look to Eradicate Thirsty Plant in West (AP 6/20)
A water-guzzling shrub with no natural enemies and an incredible ability to tolerate heat, fires, flood, and drought is spreading unchecked across the American West, while states and the Bush administration try to figure out how to stop it. The shrub, known as tamarisk or salt cedar, can drink up to 300 gallons of water per day. Across the West, the plants suck up nearly 800 billion gallons more than the native plants they have replaced -- enough water for 4.8 million people. The 10-foot tall shrub is native to Asia and the eastern Mediterranean and was imported to the US in the 1830s to serve as ornamentals, windbreaks, and erosion control. Its recent unchecked domination began when two tamarisk species formed a hybrid and spread. Each shrub can produce 500,000 to 1 million seeds per year, allowing it to spread over tens of square miles in a single season. Experts estimate that replacing tamarisk with native cottonwood, mulefat, or willows along the Colorado River alone would save up to 150 billion gallons of water annually. Such a project, however, would cost up to $500 million and could present additional problems. Scientists have been exploring the use of Chinese leaf beetles since the mid-1980s, but have not confirmed that the beetles will target only the tamarisk shrubs. For more on how your state can stop invasive species before they get started, visit: http://www.serconline.org/invasives/pkg_frameset.html.
back to top
 
Whitewater Sports Gain Recognition in Water Rights Battle (AP 6/20)
Typically ignored in favor of farmers, cities, and miners, whitewater enthusiasts and other recreational water users are gaining a foothold in the water rights battle. Administrative rulings and other provisions have guaranteed adequate river water levels for kayakers and rafters. In Texas, for example, conservation groups are utilizing a new state water management plan to guarantee minimum water flows for fish and wildlife. Recreational water rights have also been secured through court decisions. In Colorado, the cities of Golden, Vail, and Breckinridge recently won guarantees of water amounts for recreational use. In each of the cases, the state argued that such guarantees could inhibit future development through denial of water to new subdivisions, but the judges sided with the cities. Nationwide, conservation and recreation groups are working to guarantee river flows, and that effort is expected to expand in the next 15 years as hydroelectric dams require relicensing.
back to top
 
California Taking Aim at Cruise Ships (Sacramento Bee 6/23)
Cruise ships are the target of three California Senate bills aimed at reducing air and water pollution off the California coast. AB121 prohibits ships from dumping sewage, sewage sludge, or oily bilge water into state waters. AB471 prohibits ships from using onboard waste incinerators within 90 miles if the coast and would, eventually, require ships within 25 miles of the coast to use cleaner-burning diesel fuel. AB906 would prohibit the dumping of gray water and hazardous waste within state waters. Cruise ships visiting Monterey, CA, are still feeling the effects of an October mishap, when a ship discharged more than 34,000 gallons of gray water (from sinks, showers, kitchens), 260 gallons of treated black water (sewage), and 2,000 gallons of processed bilge water in a nearby marine sanctuary. The three bills attempt to standardize the law regarding dumping in California, which is currently regulated by a hodgepodge assortment of federal, international, and industry rules. The bills have already advanced through the Assembly.
back to top

For more information about SERC, or to use our services, contact our national headquarters at:
State Environmental Resource Center
106 East Doty Street, Suite 200 § Madison, Wisconsin 53703
Phone: 608-252-9800 § Fax: 608-252-9828
Email: [email protected]